Preparation H vs Tronolane - Discover The Best Hemorrhoid Cream! The Results Are Shocking!

Not sure which is better for your hemorrhoids Preparation H vs. Tronolane? The following is a detailed product comparison based on ingredients, effectiveness, and price.  You will not believe how different these two hemorrhoid creams are and what they are actually designed to do to your hemorrhoids. So, Preparation H or Tronolane, which one is it?

Take The Three Prong Approach To Hemorrhoids

As good as some of the Preparation H and Tronolane ingredients are, they do not work for everyone. Make sure to take a “multi-modal” approach to your hemorrhoids by including both a hemorrhoid wipe and hemorrhoid oral supplement to your plan of attack. Hemorrhoid wipes like Preparation H and hemorrhoid supplements like HemRid are packed with “astringent” compounds. Astringents are proven to shrink tissue and work wonders for hemorrhoids.

To see our Top Pick for Hemorrhoid Wipes - click here 

To see our Top Pick for Hemorrhoid Supplement - click here

To see our Top Pick for Hemorrhoid Creams - click here

Preparation H Ingredients vs Tronolane Ingredients - Whose Is Better?

For the first part of this comparison we look into the ingredients list to see what each product has as their active ingredients. There are two active ingredients in Tronolane, Pramoxine Hydrochloride and Zinc Oxide.

Pramoxine Hydrochloride And Zinc Oxide - Does Tronolane Have The Perfect Ingredient Combo?

We know quite a bit about both of these Tronolane ingredients. First, what is Pramoxine Hydrochloride and what does it do? Pramoxine Hydrochloride is compound which is frequently used in topically in creams and ointments which are specifically designed to relieve pain. In fact, Pramoxine Hydrochloride is categorized as a topical anesthetic. An anesthetic is something that takes away pain. Pramoxine Hydrochloride is a proven effective pain reliever that works by blocking or scrambling the nerve transmissions which report pain to your brain. 

Is Pramoxine Hydrochloride Effective At Relieving Pain?

Yes. Pramoxine Hydrochloride is so effective that it has a general “numbing effect” on the area it is topically applied. You can find Pramoxine Hydrochloride in many creams and ointments that are designed to relieve pain caused by minor cuts, scrapes, rashes and even poison oak and ivy. That leads us to the other Tronolane ingredient, Zinc Oxide.

What Is Zinc Oxide And How Can It Help My Hemorrhoids?

Zinc Oxide is a wonderful inorganic compound primarily used in creams and ointments designed to relieve diaper rash.  The formula of this inorganic compound is ZnO. Unlike Pramoxine Hydrochloride which is considered a anesthetic, Zinc Oxide is classified as a protectant. When applied topically it forms a thin layer over the skin which protects the skin from irritation. This layer is called a protective barrier and is the reason the ZnO or Zinc Oxide is classified as a protectant.

Is Zinc Oxide Effective At Reducing Irritation?

Yes. Zinc Oxide is a proven ingredient which is very effective at reducing and preventing irritation of the skin. The reason for this is because the protective layer is smooth and prevents the skin from being subject to drying out, experiencing excess friction and chaffing. This ingredient provides similar benefits to petroleum jelly. As you can imagine, if your hemorrhoids are swollen and irritated, the application of zinc oxide should provide relief and potentially cause your hemorrhoids to get better.

What Are The Preparation H Ingredients?

Unlike Tronolane which only has two active ingredients, Preparation H has four active ingredients all designed to help you get relief from your hemorrhoids. Interestingly enough, these ingredients have similar benefits to the ingredients found in Tronolane. The Preparation H ingredients are as follows: Petrolatum 71.9%, Mineral Oil 14%, Shark Liver Oil 3% and Phenylephrine HCl 0.25%. The first three ingredients, Petrolatum (petroleum jelly), Mineral Oil and Shark Liver Oil are protectectants that reduce irritation.

Phenylephrine HCL Is A Vasoconstrictor - It Shrinks Your Hemorrhoid!

The last Preparation H ingredient Phenylephrine HCL is a sympathomimetic amine. This compound is considered a vasoconstrictor, meaning in constricts or makes the blood vessel smaller. This is extremely important for someone who is suffering from hemorrhoids, because hemorrhoids are swollen vessels. That’s what makes this our favorite hemorrhoid cream ingredient.

Tronolane vs Preparation H, Which Costs More?

Here we have a tie. They are both about the same price, with some flection depending on where and when you buy it.

In the Tronolane vs Preparation H Battle, Preparation H Is Our Winner!!!

Preparation H beats Tronolane in our head to head match up because of one thing, Phenylephrine HCL. Tronolane is more a pain reliever and protectant, whereas Preparation H actually deals with the issue, swollen blood vessels by including the vasoconstrictor, Phenylephrine HCL. Please keep in mind that because we are all individuals, Phenylephrine HCL may not work for you. The use of other compounds, called astringents which also shrink your blood vessels are great to include in your treatment plan. Witch Hazel, found in wipes and hemorrhoid supplements like HemRid is a powerful astringent. Pairing your Preparation H hemorrhoid cream with Tucks pads and HemRid is the way to go. 

To see our Hemorrhoid Wipe Top Pick click here

To see our Hemorrhoid Supplement Top Pick click here