Senvie Skin Care

Preparation H vs Equate Reviews - Is Preparation H or Equate Better For Hemorrhoids?

Posted on 20 November 2017

In this Preparation H vs Equate blog post we will uncover if Preparation H or Equate is better for hemorrhoids. We’ll talk about the benefits and drawbacks of both, and ultimately which one you should choose. We are going to discuss the maximum strength formulas for both.

My Journey With Hemorrhoids

As a former sufferer of hemorrhoids, I know how terrible they can be. Fortunately, I’ve also figured out how to deal with them in the best ways possible. If you have hemorrhoids and are visiting this blog, then you probably need all the help you can get. Read on to learn more about hemorrhoids and what these creams can do for you. Oh, and I’ll let you know which one is better. If you don’t have time to read my post just scroll down to the bottom. Oh, and share this post so you can help others.

Here are just some of the things I’ve tried for my hemorrhoids

  1. Hemorrhoid Creams/Ointments
  2. Hemorrhoid Wipes
  3. Hemorrhoid Pillows
  4. Hemorrhoid Supplements
  5. Hemorrhoid Suppositories
  6. Witch Hazel
  7. Coconut Oil for hemorrhoids
  8. Vaseline
  9. Hemorrhoid Surgery (not my own, 2 immediate family members)

But, you are not here to read about my story and what I’ve tried. You are here to find out about Preparation H and Equate. So, let’s go ahead and dive right into the Active Ingredients of both.

Active Ingredients of Preparation H and Equate

The maximum strength formulas have the exact same active ingredients.

Here is the Preparation H Maximum Strength active ingredient panel

Prep H Ingredient Panel

Here is the Equate Maximum Strength active ingredient panel.

Equate Ingredient Panel

Active Ingredients: Glycerin 14.4%, Phenylephrine HCl 0.25%, Pramoxine HCl 1%, and White petrolatum 15%.

What do these active ingredients do?

Glycerin 14.4% - Glycerin is a very common skin protectant. It is used in many ointment and cream formulas, for skin conditions and for cosmetics. Glycerin forms a barrier and helps keep out toxins and prevent further irritation. Most people have no issues with using Glycerin but a seldom few will have allergic reactions to it.

Phenylephrine HCl 0.25% - This is one of the most important ingredients. Phenylephrine HCl 0.25% is a vasoconstrictor. It essentially reduces hemorrhoid tissue by shrinking arteries sonf capillaries. The great thing is that symptoms vanish as your hemorrhoids shrink and go away. A vasoconstrictor is very important to have when battling hemorrhoids.

Pramoxine HCl 1% - The is a topical pain numbing agent. Pramoxine HCl 1% blocks nerve endings so that you do not experience pain. When you have debilitating hemorrhoids like I have had, then this part of the treatment is a godsend.

White Petrolatum 15% - White Petrolatum 15% is similar to Glycerin in that it works as a skin protectant, forming a barrier between your hemorrhoid and air. This helps speed up the healing process by reducing contamination and irritation. Plus, it helps prevent aggravation from physical movement and helps lock in the other active ingredients so they can target your hemorrhoid..

Outcome: Draw

Inactive Ingredients

So, both of these maximum strength creams have the exact same active ingredients, but what about the inactive ones?

Here is the Preparation H Maximum Strength inactive ingredient list:

Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Anhydrous Citric Acid, Butylated Hydroxyanisole, Carboxymethylcellulose Sodium, Cetyl Alcohol, Citric Acid Monohydrate, Dexpanthenol, Edetate Disodium, Glyceryl Monostearate, Methylparaben, Mineral Oil, Polyoxyl Lauryl Ether, Polyoxyl Stearyl Ether, Propyl Gallate, Propylene Glycol, Propylparaben, Purified Water, Sodium Benzoate, Stearyl Alcohol, Tocopherols Excipient, Vitamin E Acetate, Xanthan Gum.

Here is the Equate Maximum Strength inactive ingredient list:

aloe barbadensis leaf extract, butylated hydroxyanisole, carboxymethylcellulose sodium, cetyl alcohol, citric acid, edetate disodium, glyceryl monostearate, laureth-23, methylparaben, mineral oil, panthenol, propyl gallate, propylparaben, purified water, sodium benzoate, steareth-2, steareth-20, stearyl alcohol, vitamin E, xanthan gum.

Which ingredients are worth noting? The both have the virtually the exact same inactive ingredients. The two main positive ones are Aloe Vera and Vitamin E.  Aso you can see, these formulas are almost identical

Outcome: Draw

Preparation H and Equate Hemorrhoid Cream Customer Reviews

Preparation H Amazon Reviews

While both have virtually the exact same ingredient list, the next best thing we can do is take a look at the reviews on top websites online to see which has a better overall satisfaction rate. We will take a look at Amazon, Walmart, Jet and Target.

Equate Amazon Reviews

Amazon

Preparation H has a total of 75 reviews with a 4.4 star rating. $11.49

Equate has a total of 77 reviews with a 4.4 star rating. $7.19

Walmart

Preparation H has a 4.3 star rating on 12 reviews. $7.44

Equate has a 4.1 star rating on 33 reviews. $4.16

Jet

Preparation H has a review rating of 4.6 on 24 total customer reviews. $11.49

Equate is currently not listed on Jet.

Target

Preparation H has 3 reviews at 4.7 star rating. $6.29

Equate is currently not listed on Target.

The reviews are very even after reviewing the top commerce websites online. After reading the reviews, some people claim there is a drop-off in quality from Preparation H to Equate. Still, some say that Equate works just as well as Preparation H. If we had to choose, we would say that Preparation H is the winner since they also have a presence on Jet & Target, and are the #1 hemorrhoid brand in the USA.

Outcome: Preparation H is the winner.

Overall Price and Value: Which is More Expensive?

Preparation H is almost double the price of Equate on all the major ecommerce sites, including Target, Amazon, Walmart & Jet. If you have hemorrhoids but are ultra dollar conscious, you can easily order Equate for hemorrhoids 1st and see if it works for you. That will save you some money right off the bat. Still, if you are very serious about getting relief for your hemorrhoids you can always pay a little extra for Preparation H, but you may be getting the exact same product. The cheapest we found Equate was for $4.16 at Walmart. If you spend more than $25 you get free shipping. The cheapest we found Preparation H was $6.29 at Target, but you would have to spend more than $25 for free shipping. 

preparation h vs equate

Amazon

Preparation H - $11.49

Equate - $7.19

Walmart

Preparation H - $7.44

Equate - $4.16

Jet

Preparation H - $11.49

Equate is currently not listed on Jet.

Target

Preparation - $6.29

Equate is currently not listed on Target.

Final Review: Preparation H or Equate?

After reviewing all the evidence, we would have to suggest Preparation H over Equate. Preparation H is a more popular and trusted brand. They have several products for hemorrhoids and the maximum strength cream is our #1 pick. Equate is an excellent option if you would like to save a few bucks when you make your hemorrhoid purchase. But, if you want to go for quality over savings we would suggest Preparation H.

More Posts

0 comments

Leave a comment

All blog comments are checked prior to publishing

Search our store