Mederma vs Kelo Cote - Full Review, Which Works Better?
Posted on 29 December 2016
Get ready for the clash between Kelo Cote and Mederma. In this post we will discover which scar treatment is the best.
If you’re in the market for a scar treatment, you clearly want to invest your money in a product that will live up to the hype. The aisles are full of products that offer to erase scars, but experts say the most important ingredient a scar treatment product is silicone, which traps in moisture, a process that is essential to healing.
In that regard, Kelo-Cote Advanced Therapy Scar Gel got it right. Designed to address both old and new scars, including surgical scars, scars from cuts, burns or other injuries, C-section scars, scars following cosmetic procedures and other scars, Kelo Cote is a patented silicone that applies easily and dries quickly, creating a protective barrier to lock in moisture.
In a six-month study out of India, the use of silicone resulted in significant improvement in the look and feel of scar tissue. “Topical silicone gel is safe and effective treatment for hypertrophic and keloid scars. It is easy to apply and cosmetically acceptable,” researchers wrote in the literature accompanying the study.
If you’re comparing products and looking at Kelo-Cote or Mederma, remember that silicone is the only ingredient the formula for Kelo-Cote Advanced Therapy Scar Cream contains. While it can help prevent the production of excess collagen at the site of the scar by retaining moisture that prevents scabs, it does not offer nutrients that can speed the healing process.
Mederma, one of the most well-known scar treatment products on the market thanks to its marketing, contains allium cepa, an onion extract that has an impact on collagen production and helps reducing inflammation. (Onion was apparently used by French courtesan Ninon de L'Enclos as a method of helping her to retain her youth well into her 90s.).
Mederma, however, contains no silicone to trap in the scar-fighting compounds to speed the healing process. So which product is better? Both offer before and after photographs, and both are fairly well received by consumers. Kelo-Cote has a 76 percent approval rating of 4 stars or above on Amazon.com (the product is available there and through Factory OTC, a site devoted to health and wellness items) while Mederma has a 68 percent approval rating.
While you could mix the two and use both Kelo-Cote and Mederma together to improve the success of your scar treatment process, we recommend you consult a doctor first to make sure they are both right for you. Using multiple products can potentially cause skin interactions and we wouldn't want that for you.
Silicone is key to scar treatment.
Most experts say the most important ingredient a scar treatment product is silicone, which traps in moisture, which is essential to healing.
A 2011 study found that silicone helped better heal scars on rabbit test subjects that rabbits that were not treated with silicone. “Topically applied silicone gel is an effective treatment in the management of hypertrophic scars,” said experts from the Laboratory for Wound Repair and Regenerative Medicine’s Division of Plastic Surgery at Chicago’s Northwestern University.
Another study, this one a six-month study out of India, found that silicone has a significant positive impact on the look and feel of scar tissue. “Topical silicone gel is safe and effective treatment for hypertrophic and keloid scars. It is easy to apply and cosmetically acceptable,” researchers wrote in the literature accompanying the study.
So, while Bio-Oil and Mederma get all the hype, you would likely see better success using a product containing silicone. Again, there are many on the market – most of the simply silicone in one form or another – but none of these address the healing that should haven beneath the skin’s surface for the best results.
Mederma or Kelo Cote? Extra Nutrients Make All the Difference
A good scar treatment cream will include ingredients that perform a variety of functions beyond protecting skin from toxins and slowing the production of collagen at the site of the scar.
Quality products also feature nutrients that moisturizer to soften the texture of an existing scar, encourage the production of collagen beneath the scar tissue, slough off surface layers to reveal healthy new cells and lighten the color of the scar.
Products from nature are a better option if you’re looking for a superior scar cream. Senvie’s Selevax, an all-natural scar treatment cream which has earned 4- or 5-star ratings from 88 percent of consumers, not only includes silicone in the form of dimethicone, it also features a nutrient-dense ingredient list that goes beneath the skin’s surface to the dermis layer, where true healing begins.
Selevax’s lineup of powerhouse ingredients starts with hydrating shea butter, which not only hydrates but also includes vitamin A, which encourages an increase in the production of collagen, which ensures that the skin beneath the scar is healthier, but also helps speed the turnover of surface cells, so the healthy new cells beneath are revealed faster.
It also offers antioxidants including C, D and E to fight off free radicals and protect healthy, new skin cells and both rose hip and arnica oils, both of which have been clinically proven to improve the color and texture of scar tissue. Arnica oil is especially effective at not only treating scars, but also helping to prevent scarring after surgery. According to Dr. Gabrielle Francis, a holistic physician at the Herban Alchemist in New York City, arnica oil is an amazing treatment for surgical scars, and is one she recommends to clients to use both before and after surgical procedures, first to prepare skin, secondly, to repair it. “We’ll start three days before the surgery and for two weeks after,” Francis said. “People’s surgeons always tell them, ‘We’ve never had anybody heal as fast as you.’”
Selevax, which is only $1.45 more than the $27.50 Keto Cote price tag on Amazon, also includes silicone in the form of dimethicone, so nutrients are better able to penetrate the skin’s surface and reach the dermis layer where they can do the most work.
Selevax is made in the United States and offers a variety of benefits designed to help you feel comfortable when making your purchase, including customer reviews, before and after photos and a money-back guarantee if you don’t see similar results. Selevax is available on the Senvie website and Amazon.com.