Mederma vs Bio Oil For Scars & Stretch Marks - Full Review
Posted on 19 December 2016 by Maryanne Johnson
Share this post
If you’re in the market for a scar treatment, then this Mederma vs. Bio Oil Review will help. There are so many to choose from it makes it almost impossible to know which one will give you the results you’re looking for, and which ones will be a big waste of money.
While both are good scar fighting options, our top scar cream called Selevax is our #1 pick for scars.
Not only does Selevax contain a great mix of natural ingredients for scars like Rose Hip Seed Oil, Arnica Oil, and Shea Butter, it also contains dimethicone (silicone) which in our opinion makes it a much better options for getting rid of scars. Research supports the use of silicone in cream to treat scars (1).
Table of Contents [hide]
The aisles are packed with products that offer to erase scars, so how do you know which one to choose?
Mederma, one of the most well-known scar treatment products on the market thanks to its marketing investment, contains allium cepa, an onion extract that has an impact on collagen production and helps reducing inflammation.
Onion was among the products included in French courtesan Ninon de L'Enclos’s beauty arsenal, and was said to help her retain her youth into her 90s.
Mederma Reviews VS Bio Oil Reviews
But Bio-Oil – which advertises in most women’s magazines, hitting their target market perfectly – is not far behind.
Bio-Oil – released in 1987 and based on a similar Swiss product - contains a wide range of essential oils, including lavender, chamomile and rosemary oils to heal, calendula to moisturize and vitamins A and E to help right free radicals and protect new skin cells by acting as antioxidants.
It also contains the proprietary blend PurCellin Oil, which helps reduce the thickness of the oil so it can penetrate beneath the skin’s surface, reaching the dermis layer where real healing can begin.
Both are available in most superstores, department stores and drug stores as well as through Amazon.com, although Mederma has a higher price point than the Bio-Oil. But both have something missing.
Mederma or Bio Oil For Scars and Stretch Marks?
Silicone is key to scar treatment. Most experts say the most important ingredient in a scar treatment product is silicone. Silicone traps in moisture, which is essential to healing.
A 2011 study found that silicone helped better heal scars. “Topically applied silicone gel is an effective treatment in the management of hypertrophic scars,” said experts from the Laboratory for Wound Repair and Regenerative Medicine’s Division of Plastic Surgery at Chicago’s Northwestern University.
Another study, this one a six-month study out of India, found that silicone has a significant positive impact on the look and feel of scar tissue.
“Topical silicone gel is safe and effective treatment for hypertrophic and keloid scars. It is easy to apply and cosmetically acceptable,” researchers wrote in the literature accompanying the study.
So while Bio-Oil and Mederma get all the hype, you might see better success using a product containing silicone, like Selevax.
Again, there are many on the market – most of the simply silicone in one form or another – but none of these address the layer beneath the skin’s surface which is important for best results, like Selevax does.
Some scars can actually take up to two to three years to fully mature and turn pale (2).
So, the sooner the better when it comes to treating your scars.
Bio Oil vs Mederma During Pregnancy
Whenever you have a medical question regarding a product it is always wise to consult a doctor. We don't know which product would be better to use when pregnant or if either product is okay to use when pregnant.
Using Mederma and Bio Oil Together
Can I use mederma and bio oil at the same time? If you do decide to use both mederma and bio oil at the same time we recommend you use with caution. Often times, products work well and are generally safe to use on their own.
Once you start using multiple products at the same time you are combining ingredients that may not be safe to use together.
Once again you can always check with your doctor to see if the ingredients from multiple products are safe to use at once.
Bio Oil VS Mederma For Surgical Scars
For surgical scars, we think Bio-Oil is the right choice after reading reviews and doing online research. Mederma seems to be a hit or miss product, like many scar creams.
Bio-Oil is cheaper and seems to have a better reputation in this area. Please note that for surgical scars it can take a very long time to see adequate results.
So, if you purchase a scar cream or scar oil like bio-oil make sure you give it the proper time to work.
Do not expect results too quickly, at least give it a full month or so to see if Bio-Oil or Mederma really work. But before you buy either, try a product with silicone first, like Selevax.
Is Selevax by Senvie a Better Option For Scars?
With Senvie’s Selevax, silicone creates a protective seal that locks in moisture, helping to prevent the production of excess collagen at the site of the scar while time-tested nutrients help speed the healing process.
Quality products also feature nutrients that moisturizer to soft the texture of an existing scar, encourage the body's natural production of collagen beneath the scar tissue, slough off surface layers to reveal healthy new cells and lighten the color of the scar.
Products from nature are a better option.
Selevax’s lineup of powerhouse ingredients starts with hydrating shea butter, which not only hydrates but also includes vitamin A, which encourages an increase in the production of collagen.
This ensures that the skin beneath the scar is healthier, but also helps speed the turnover of surface cells, so the healthy new cells beneath are revealed faster.
It also offers antioxidants including C, D and E to fight off free radicals and protect healthy, new skin cells and both rose hip and arnica oils, both of which have been clinically proven to improve the color and texture of scar tissue.
Arnica oil is especially effective at not only treating scars, but also helping to prevent scarring after surgery.
According to Dr. Gabrielle Francis, a holistic physician at the Herban Alchemist in New York City, arnica oil is an amazing treatment for surgical scars, and is one she recommends to clients to use both before and after surgical procedures, first to prepare skin, secondly, to repair it. “We’ll start three days before the surgery and for two weeks after,” Francis said. “People’s surgeons always tell them, ‘We’ve never had anybody heal as fast as you.’”
A Product That Really Works For Scars
Looking for an all natural option for scars? Try Selevax by Senvie and see a fast reduction in the appearance of your scars. Selevax is made in the USA and contains a plethora of high-quality natural ingredients like
Shea Butter, Arnica Oil, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Rose Hip Seed Oil, Sunflower Oil and Tocopherol.
Abnormal scars can cause significant unpleasant symptoms including disfigurement, functional limitations, and psychosocial issues like depression (3).
Selevax works fast to reduce the appearance of your scars. Try it today risk-free with a 90-day money back guarantee and free shipping on all orders in the USA.