Bio-Oil vs. Palmer’s Cocoa Butter for Stretch Marks - Discover The Truth About Bio-Oil and Palmer's
Posted on 10 July 2017
Get the full Bio-Oil vs. Palmer’s Cocoa Butter for Stretch Marks Review here. If you're going to purchase one of these products for your stretch marks, you better read this first!
If you’re suffering from stretch marks – caused when the skin stretches and the dermis layer, made up of collagen and elastin proteins, isn’t strong enough to support the tension – you’ve likely researched numerous products in search of the right one to help you alleviate your skin condition and ease your embarrassment.
There are two popular products on the market, Bio-Oil and Palmer’s Cocoa Butter, both of which can be found on the shelves of nearly every drug store or retail outlet such as Wal-Mart or Target, that have garnered the most attention for their ability to either heal or prevent stretch marks by keeping skin cells healthy and strong.
If you’re in the market, should you choose Bio-Oil or Palmer’s Cocoa Butter for stretch marks?
We are here to break it down for you, giving you an idea about which product – Palmer’s Cocoa Butter or Bio Oil – is a better option.
According to the product’s website, Bio-Oil has become the best-selling product to treat scars and stretch marks in 24 countries since its global launch in 2002. (A German cosmetic scientist formulated the product when he discovered an oil that was a natural carrier for botanical nutrients.)
Its ingredients include:
- Calendula Officinalis Flower Extract. Calendula oil helps soften skin, and it is gentle enough for a baby. It also helps ease inflammation associated with damaged skin.
- Lavandula Angustifolia Oil. Lavender oil helps promote the production of collagen and elastin, strengthening the dermis layer where stretch marks are formed.
- Rosmarinus Officinalis Leaf Oil. Rosemary oil helps soften and smooth skin while evening out skin tone, helping to reduce the appearance of scars.
- Anthemis Nobilis Flower Oil. Chamomile oil contains properties that help reduce the appearance of scars, along with moisture to improve scar tissue’s texture.
- PurCellin Oil. This propriety blend is a synthetic version of duck preening gland oil, which helps keep ducks’ feathers waterproof and helps this formula better absorb into human skin.
- Tocopheryl Acetate. Vitamin E is a skin-friendly antioxidant that helps protect collagen and elastin from free radical damage while hydrating skin with welcome moisture that keeps it supple and pliable.
- Retinyl Palmitate. Vitamin A helps smooth roughness, so scar tissue will be less noticeable. It also helps strengthen collagen and elastin skin proteins so skin is less likely to tear.
Bio-Oil has a 79 percent approval rating on Amazon (four or five stars), where the majority of satisfied users have given it a five-star rating.
Of the negative reviews of three stars and below, many said the product did not have any noticeable effects on their stretch mark scars. One reviewer said she saw no benefits even after years of regular use.
Palmer’s Cocoa Butter
In the research to determine whether Bio-Oil is better than Palmer’s Cocoa Butter, we compared Bio-Oil to Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Massage Stretch Mark Cream, which had a similar ingredient list. The original Palmer’s Cocoa Butter formula, which contains cocoa butter and vitamin E, had no other ingredients to help target stretch marks.
This makes it a fair battle comparing Palmer’s Cocoa Butter vs. Bio-Oil.
Palmers Cocoa Butter Massage Stretch Mark Cream formula includes:
- Cocoa butter. Cocoa butter contains antioxidants including the fatty acids oleic acid, palmitic acid, and stearic acid. Each target free radicals that can damage collagen and elastin, the skin protein cells that are less likely to tear when strong and healthy.
- Vitamin E. This skin-friendly antioxidant helps protect collagen and elastin from free radical damage while hydrating skin with rich moisture.
- Argan oil. Argan oil is packed with vitamins A and E, both of which offers tremendous skin benefits, as well as antioxidants to protect collagen and elastin skin cells, omega-6 fatty acids to help moisturize skin, and linoleic acid, another fatty acid that helps offer hydration while reducing inflammation.
- Almond oil. Almond oil has two big benefits. It not only helps hydrate skin – and penetrates the surface easily, where it can help the dermis layer heal - it also acts as a gentle, natural exfoliator, lifting away the skin’s surface cells to reveal healthier cells beneath.
- Shea butter. Shea butter is a great moisturizer that melts on contact with skin, allowing it to penetrate the surface easily. It is also packed with antioxidants to help protect skin from damage.
- Collagen. Collagen makes up nearly 80 percent of skin, and provides structure and elasticity. It also helps the dermis layer retain moisture that’s essential for healing.
- Elastin. Elastin is the skin protein that helps skin retain its flexibility, and snap back after stretching.
Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Stretch Mark Cream reviews
Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Stretch Mark Cream scored slightly lower than Bio-Oil on Amazon, earning an approval rating of 77 percent, with most users giving it a rating of four or five stars.
So, in a head-to-head, it would appear that Bio-Oil and Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Stretch Mark Cream are basically tied. While each have slightly different formulas – Palmer’s heavy hitter is cocoa butter, while Bio-Oil would say the innovative PurCellin Oil is its most important ingredient – each achieves similar results. Both have the same levels of effectiveness not only for preventing stretch marks, but also for helping stretch marks heal.
Both are available through a variety of different locations, including Amazon, CVS, Walgreens, Rite Aid, Wal-Mart and Target as well as other online vendors. Bio-Oil has a slightly higher price point than Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Stretch Mark Cream, although, on Amazon, the difference is negligible.